Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-hfldf Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-05-18T14:04:32.093Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Cosmopolitan underworld: opiate refinement in inter-war Istanbul

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  06 May 2024

Daniel-Joseph MacArthur-Seal Open the ORCID record for Daniel-Joseph MacArthur-Seal [Opens in a new window]
Daniel-Joseph MacArthur-Seal*
Affiliation:
Global History and Governance, Scuola Superiore Meridionale, Naples, Italy
*
Email: d.macarthurseal@ssmeridionale.it
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The Turkish government’s suppression of private heroin factories and its monopolization of opium exports brought the state into conflict with a large numbers of Istanbul residents who sought to profit from the lucrative trade in opiates. Sites of clandestine drug production spread across the urban and suburban landscape, inspiring public alarm and new policing measures. The article examines the human networks behind these production sites, investigating how they utilized the diversity of their members and contacts in the search for profit and the evasion of the state, and how this diversity was interpreted in press and public debate.

Type
Research Article
Information
Urban History , First View , pp. 1 - 17
Check for updates
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2024. Published by Cambridge University Press

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 United Nations Library and Archives, Geneva (LON) R3188/12/34612/3541, ‘Report on mission to Turkey by the director of the Opium Traffic and Social Questions Section’, 26 Feb. 1932, 4.

2 McAllister, W.T.B., Drug Diplomacy in the Twentieth Century: An International History (London, 2000), 108 Google Scholar; Erdinç, F.C., Overdose Türkiye: Türkiye’de Eroin, Kaçakçılığı, Bağımlılığı ve Politikalar (Istanbul, 2004), 124–9Google Scholar; B. Çıtır, ‘Osmanlı’dan cumhuriyet’e Türkiye’de afyon ziraati ve ticareti (1900–1939)’, Sakarya University MA thesis, 2015, 120–2; S. Altan, , ‘Cenevre afyon konferansları ve Türkiye’nin tutumu’, Çanakkale Araştırmaları Türk Yıllığı, 17 (2019), 45–70 CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 59–61; Gürsoy, O.B., ‘Losing wealth or restricting the poison? Changing opium policies in early Republican Turkey, 1923–1945’, Historia Agraria: Revista de Agricultura e Historia Rural, 61 (2013), 115–43Google Scholar, at 126–7; R. Gingeras, Heroin, Organized Crime, and the Making of Modern Turkey (Oxford, 2014), 72–3; M. Bacci, ‘Smugglers and state-builders: opiate trafficking and institutional development in interwar Egypt and Turkey’, University of Texas at Austin MA thesis, 2017, 52–3.

3 See Gotsinas, K., ‘Attitudes towards heroin addicts and addiction in interwar Greece’, Central Europe, 12 (2014), 174–94CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 183–4; MacArthur-Seal, D.-J., ‘The trans-Asian pathways of “Oriental products”: navigating prohibition between Turkey, China and Japan, 1918–1938’, Modern Asian Studies, 56 (2021), 207–49CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 234–5.

4 Ş.Y. Sarıbaş, Altıncı Milli Türk Tıb Kongresi: Alkoldan Başka Zehirlerle (Uyuşturucu Maddelerle) Toksikomani (Ankara, 1935), 55.

5 Vakit, 27 Jun. 1933, 1.

6 L. Paoli and T. Vander Beken, ‘Organized crime: a contested concept’, in L. Paoli (ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Organized Crime (Oxford, 2014), 16–17.

7 E.C. Schneider, Smack: Heroin and the American City (Philadelphia, 2008), 85–92; Murji, K., ‘Hierarchies, markets and networks: ethnicity/race and drug distribution’, Journal of Drug Issues, 37 (2007), 781–804 CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 785.

8 Sluga, G. and Horne, J., ‘Cosmopolitanism: its pasts and practices’, Journal of World History, 21 (2010), 369–73CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 371.

9 Gekas, A., ‘Compradors to cosmopolitans? The historiographical fortunes of merchants in eastern Mediterranean ports’, European University Institute Working Papers, 29 (2008), 95–114 Google Scholar; Hanley, W., ‘Grieving cosmopolitanism in Middle East studies’, History Compass, 6 (2008), 1346–67CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

10 Sifneos, E., ‘Cosmopolitanism as a feature of the Greek commercial diaspora’, History and Anthropology, 16 (2005), 97–111 CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 100.

11 Huber, V. and Jensen, J.C., ‘Dealing with difference: cosmopolitanism in the nineteenth-century world of empires’, Humanity, 12 (2021), 39–46 CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 39.

12 K. Fahmy, ‘For Cavafy, with love and squalor: some critical notes on the history and historiography of modern Alexandria’, in A. Hirst and M.S. Silk (eds.), Alexandria, Real and Imagined (Aldershot, 2004), 264; Schayegh, C., ‘The many worlds of `Abud Yasin; or, what narcotics trafficking in the interwar Middle East can tell us about territorialization’, American Historical Review, 116 (2011), 273–306 CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed.

13 Freitag, U., ‘Cosmopolitanism in the Middle East as part of global history’, ZMO Programmatic Texts, 4 (2010), 3Google Scholar.

14 Metinsoy, M., ‘“Sosyal kaçakçılık”: Erken cumhuriyet Türkiyesi’nde tekellere direniş’, Siyasal: Journal of Political Sciences, 29 (2020), 247–69Google Scholar, at 253.

15 Büyük Salname (Istanbul, 1925–26), 892–3; Türk Ticaret Salnamesi (Istanbul, 1926–27), 647; Ticaret Salnamesi (Istanbul, 1927), 973; Büyük Ticaret Salnamesi (Istanbul, 1928), 528.

16 Yaşar, A., ‘A convivial space: the urban khan in Ottoman Istanbul from the mid-eighteenth to the mid-nineteenth centuries’, Middle Eastern Studies, 59 (2023), 539–50CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 541; İstanbul Hanları: Alfebetik Rehberi (Istanbul, 1946).

17 Now known as Meydancık (little plaza) Han.

18 Türkiye Salnamesi (Istanbul, 1927), 992.

19 Afyon Türkiye’de ve Dünyada (Ankara, 1935), 39.

20 Güllü, R.E., ‘Saltanatın kaldırılmasının ardından İstanbul bürokrasisinin T.B.M.M. hükümetine bağlanma süreci ve İstanbul Türklüğü’nün muhafazası tartışmaları’, Türk Dünyası Araştırmaları, 116 (2017), 119–44Google Scholar, at 140–1.

21 Altan, ‘Cenevre afyon konferansları ve Türkiye’nin tutumu’, 55.

22 Gingeras, Heroin, 36.

23 İ. Tekeli, ‘Modernleşme sürecinde İstanbul’un nüfus dinamikleri nasış değerlendirilmeli’, in M. Güvenç (ed.), Eski İstanbullular, Yeni İstanbullular (Istanbul, 2009), 193–4.

24 Okan, O.C., ‘Projections of xenophobia: the capitulations, employment, and Anglo-Turkish relations in the 1920s’, Yıllık, 4 (2022), 45–66 Google Scholar, at 49.

25 A. Aktar, Nationalism and Non-Muslim Minorities in Turkey, 1915–1950 (London, 2021), 124.

26 Resmi Gazete, 558 (6 Feb. 1927), 1.

27 R. Bali, Xenophobia and Protectionism: A Study of the 1932 Law Reserving Majority of Occupations in Turkey to Turkish Nationals (Istanbul, 2013), 13.

28 R. Bali, Bir Türkleştirme Serüveni (1923–1945) (Istanbul, 1999), 218.

29 Erdinç, Overdose Türkiye, 117.

30 A. Aktar, Varlık Vergisi ve ‘Türkleştirme’ Politikaları (Istanbul, 2000), 123.

31 Milliyet, 11 Apr. 1933, 1.

32 Öztan, R.H., ‘The Great Depression and the making of Turkish–Syrian border, 1921–1939’, International Journal of Middle East Studies, 52 (2020), 311–26CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

33 Demirtük, S. and Kaya, M., ‘1929 dünya ekonomik bunalımı’nda İzmir’de kaçakçılık, yankesicilik, gasp, hırsızlık faaliyetleri ve kökenleri’, 21 . Yüzyılda Eğitim ve Toplum, 2 (2013), 163–81Google Scholar, at 170.

34 Vakit, 24 Sep. 1933, 10.

35 C. Woodall, ‘Decadent nights: a cocaine-filled reading of 1920s post-Ottoman Istanbul’, in M. Ardizzoni and V. Ferme (eds.), Mediterranean Encounters in the City: Frameworks of Mediation between East and West, North and South (London, 2015), 25–7.

36 Şükrü, Ahmet, ‘Heroinomani’, Türk Nöro-Psihiatri Gazetesi, 1 (1933), 1–5 Google Scholar.

37 LON R4796, letter from Refik Saydam to Eric Einar Ekstrand, 11 Jun. 1936.

38 Sarıbaş, Toksikomani, 54.

39 Cumhuriyet, 4 Oct. 1933, 1.

40 S. Kayıhan, Afyon ve Diğer Uyuşturucu Maddeler (Istanbul, 1946), 324.

41 Çakır, G., ‘Türkiye’de uyuşturucu maddelere yönelik geliştirilen politakalar (1920–1950)’, Akademik Tarih ve Araştırmalar Dergisi, 5 (2021), 106–37Google Scholar, at 115.

42 Cumhuriyet, 29 Mar. 1932, 2.

43 Milliyet, 29 Mar. 1932, 3.

44 E.J. Zürcher, The Unionist Factor: The Role of the Committee of Union and Progress in the Turkish National Movement, 1905–1926 (Leiden, 1984), 104.

45 Cumhuriyet, 30 Mar. 1932, 3.

46 Gingeras, Heroin, 71–5.

47 R.E. Kocu, Istanbul Ansiklopedesi, vol. VII (Istanbul, 1963), 3568.

48 Milliyet, 29 Mar. 1932, 3.

49 LON R4800, ‘Illicit traffic in and clandestine manufacture of drugs discovered at Istanbul in August 1937’, 9 Sep. 1937; LON R4792, ‘Discovery at Pera, Istanbul, on 28th April, 1934, of a new clandestine narcotic drug factory controlled by Armando Borzalini and other persons’, 22 May 1934; LON R4790, ‘Discovery of a clandestine morphine factory at Pera on June 22nd, 1933’, 8 Jul. 1933; LON R4799, ‘Clandestine manufacture of heroin by Mihail Calogridis and Caliopi Nicolaidi, recently discovered at Istanbul’, 11 Feb. 1937.

50 Özil, A., ‘Skyscrapers of the past and their shadows: a social history of urbanity in late Ottoman Istanbul’, International Journal of Turkish Studies, 21 (2015), 75–94 Google Scholar, at 88.

51 LON R4799, ‘Discovery of a clandestine drug factory at Istanbul’, 10 May 1937.

52 LON R4794, ‘Discovery of a clandestine drug factory at Istanbul on June 13th to 14th, 1935’, 5 Jul. 1935; LON R4800, ‘Discovery of the clandestine manufacture of heroin in a villa at Yechilkeuy, near Istanbul, during the night of June 15th–16th, 1937’, 17 Aug. 1937; LON R4803, ‘Discovery of a factory for the manufacture of drugs at Kouroutchechme, Bosphorus, on June 2nd, 1938’, 31 Aug. 1938; Akşam, 13 Feb. 1935, 1; LON R4794, ‘Discovery of a clandestine narcotic drugs factory in a house at Bebek (Bosphorus), on March 3rd, 1935 (Nico Borzalini case)’, 4 May 1935; LON R4806, ‘Discovery of a case of clandestine manufacture of drugs at Istanbul on March 7th, 1939’, 8 May 1939; LON R4796, ‘Discovery of two clandestine drug factories in Turkey in November 1935, the first at Emirghan (Upper Bosphorus) and the second at Bakirkeuy near Istanbul, with a branch at Sorgun near Akchehir’, 8 Jan. 1936; LON R4796, letter from Refik Saydam to Eric Einar Ekstrand, 11 Jun. 1936; LON R4800, ‘Discovery of a clandestine drug factory at Prinkipo, Princes Islands, Turkey, on May 12th, 1937’, 12 Jul. 1937.

53 Stamboul, 13 Apr. 1933, 2; Bayraktar, U.B., ‘(Social) Darwinism for families: the magazine Muhit, children and women in early Republican Turkey’, European Journal of Turkish Studies, 16 (2013), 7Google Scholar.

54 Ulus, 30 Nov. 1934, 6.

55 Bernard Blumenthal was sometimes written as Bernar Blümental or Blumentali in the Turkish press. It should be noted that there was little consistency in the spelling of non-Turkish names in Turkish print. The situation is further complicated by differences between English and French transliterations of Turkish, Greek and Armenian names. To the best ability of the author, names are transliterated here according to modern standard conventions of transliteration for each language.

56 Cumhuriyet, 14 Apr. 1933, 2.

57 Le Journal d’Orient, 11 Apr. 1933, 1.

58 Akşam, 10 Apr. 1933, 2.

59 Ibid., 11 Apr. 1933, 1–5.

60 Ibid.

61 Vakit, 10 Apr. 1933, 1.

62 Ibid., 13 Apr. 1933, 6.

63 Cumhuriyet, 4 Oct. 1933, 1.

64 Centre des Archives Diplomatiques de Nantes 258 PO/B/42, ‘Memo by N.I.B.’, 23 Dec. 1931; Erdinç, Overdose Türkiye, 112–13.

65 Stamboul, 13 Apr. 1933, 2

66 Aktar, A., ‘A critical analysis of the Turkish press discourse against non-Muslims: a case analysis of the newspaper coverage of the 1942 wealth tax’, Middle Eastern Studies, 47 (2011), 605–21,Google Scholar at 612.

67 E. Eldem, ‘(A quest for) the bourgeoisie of Istanbul: identities, roles and conflicts’, in U. Freitag and N. Lafi (eds.), Urban Governance under the Ottomans: Between Cosmopolitanism and Conflict (Abingdon and New York, 2014), 163–5.

68 Cumhuriyet, 25 Jun. 1933, 2.

69 LON C.498.M.251, ‘Summary of illicit transactions and seizures, 1 Apr.– 30. June 1933’, 4.

70 Ibid.

71 G. Harlaftis, ‘Greek maritime business in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries: a paradigm for comparative studies on family capitalism and diaspora networks’, in F. de Goey and J.W. Veluwenkamp (eds.), Entrepreneurs and Institutions in Europe and Asia, 1500–2000 (Amsterdam, 2002), 83.

72 Resmi Gazete, 2435 (24 Jun. 1933), 2777–8.

73 Cumhuriyet, 20 Jul. 1933, 4.

74 Ibid., 10 Aug. 1933, 2.

75 Ibid., 23 Apr. 1934, 2.

76 Ibid., 26 Feb. 1934, 2.

77 Ibid., 6 Sep. 1933, 5.

78 Ibid., 4 Oct. 1933, 2.

79 D. Gross, A Banker’s Journey: How Edmund J. Safra Built a Global Financial Empire (New York, 2022), 60; M. Caraco, La famille Calderon, ou, chronique de la vie juive de Constantinople au debut du 20e siècle (Istanbul, 2002), 7.

80 Cumhuriyet, 7 Sep. 1933, 1.

81 Vakit, 7 Sep. 1933, 10.

82 Gingeras, R., ‘Beyond Istanbul’s “Laz underworld”: Ottoman paramilitarism and the rise of Turkish organized crime, 1908–1950’, Journal of Contemporary European History, 19 (2010), 215–30CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 224; C. Yelbaşı, ‘Civil war, violence and nationality from empire to nation state: the Circassians in Turkey (1918–1938)’, SOAS Ph.D. thesis, 2017, 33.

83 See for example LON R4794, ‘Discovery of a clandestine narcotic drugs factory in a house at Bebek (Bosphorus), on March 3rd, 1935, (Nico Borzalini case)’, 4 May 1935; LON R4794, ‘Discovery of a clandestine drug factory at Istanbul on June 13th to 14th, 1935’, 5 Jul. 1935.

84 Gingeras, Heroin, 69–70.

85 Cumhuriyet, 7 Sep. 1933, 1; LON R4790, ‘Discovery of a secret drugs factory at Istanbul in September 1933’, 27 Sep. 1933.

86 National Archives and Records Administration consular files Istanbul vol. 474, letter from Charles E. Allen to secretary of state, 22 Dec. 1932; LON C.498.M.251, ‘Summary of illicit transactions and seizures, 1 Apr.– 30. June 1933’, 4; Marianne, 22 Feb. 1933, 8.

87 Gingeras, Heroin, 75; Block, A.A., ‘European drug traffic and traffickers between the wars: the policy of suppression and its consequences’, Journal of Social History, 23 (1989), 325.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

88 Cumhuriyet, 14 Apr. 1933, 2.

89 Ibid., 2 Oct. 1933, 1; ibid., 13 Nov. 1933, 1–2.

90 Afyon Türkiye’de ve Dünyada, 30.

91 Cumhuriyet, 14 Apr. 1933, 2.

92 M. Galeotti, ‘Turkish organized crime: from tradition to business’, in D. Siegel and H. van de Bunt (eds.), Traditional Organized Crime in the Modern World (New York, 2012), 53.