No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Before Stockholm: Emotions and Victimhood in Mediterranean Kidnapping Narratives, 1866–1921
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 26 February 2024
Abstract
Fifty years ago, the infamous bank robbery and ensuing hostage crisis that took place in a Stockholm bank gave rise to the so-called ‘Stockholm syndrome’. Though never recognized as a valid medical diagnosis, the (allegedly) pathological relationship between kidnapper and hostage has become an omnipresent media phenomenon that inspires movies and television series to this day. However, this forced bond was not always seen as problematic. The years between 1860 and 1910 witnessed the rise of kidnappings in the Mediterranean world (Southern Italy, Greece, the Ottoman Balkan region, and Morocco) involving English, American, and European hostages. Today, we know about these incidents from autobiographical narratives by the former captives. They painted a surprisingly favourable picture of their captors – and found enthusiastic audiences for their stories. Looking at the interplay of feelings, coercion, and empowerment, the article opens up a new perspective on the history of emotions that brings both victims and perpetrators into the picture.
- Type
- Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © The Author(s), 2024. Published by Cambridge University Press.
References
1 Perdicaris, Ion, ‘Morocco, the land of the extreme West and the story of my captivity’, National Geographic Magazine, 17 (1906), pp. 117–57Google Scholar, at p. 150.
2 Tuchman, Barbara W., ‘Perdicaris alive or Raisuli dead’, American Heritage, 10 (1959), pp. 18–21, 98–101Google Scholar; Baepler, Paul, ‘Rewriting the barbary captivity narrative: the Perdicaris affair and the last barbary pirate’, Prospects, 24 (1999), pp. 177–221CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
3 Perdicaris, Ion, ‘In Raissuli’s hands: the story of my captivity and deliverance May 18 to June 26, 1904’, Leslie’s Monthly Magazine, 58 (1904), pp. 510–22Google Scholar; idem, ‘Morocco’.
4 Idem, ‘Morocco’, p. 152.
5 See, in particular, Blinkhorn, Martin, ‘Liability, responsibility and blame: British ransom victims in the Mediterranean periphery, 1860–1881’, Australian Journal of Politics and History, 46 (2000), pp. 336–56CrossRefGoogle Scholar; idem, ‘Avoiding the ultimate act of violence: Mediterranean bandits and kidnapping for ransom, 1815–1914’, in Stuart Carroll, ed., Cultures of violence: interpersonal violence in historical perspective (Basingstoke and New York, NY, 2007), pp. 192–211.
6 Lichtensteiger, Johann Jakob, Vier Monate unter den Briganten in den Abruzzen (Zurich, 1910), pp. 65–7Google Scholar (my translation).
7 One of the first attempts to define Stockholm syndrome was made at the international conference ‘Dimensions of victimization in the context of terroristic acts’, held in Evian, France, from 3 to 5 June 1977. Quotes from Ochberg, Frank, ‘The victim of terrorism – psychiatric considerations’, in Creslinsten, Ronald D., ed., Final report on ‘dimensions of victimization in the context of terroristic acts’ (Montreal, 1977), pp. 13–35Google Scholar, at pp. 21, 28.
8 Lang, Daniel, ‘A reporter at large: the bank drama’, New Yorker, 25 (1974), pp. 56–126Google Scholar.
9 Jared R. Tinklenberg, Peggy Murphy, and Patricia Murphy, ‘Adaptive behavior of victims of terrorism’, in Creslinsten, ed., Final report, pp. 93–107, at p. 99.
10 Jameson, Celia, ‘The “short step” from love to hypnosis: a reconsideration of the Stockholm syndrome’, Journal for Cultural Research, 14 (2010), pp. 337–55, at p. 343CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
11 Susan L. Carruthers, Cold War captives: imprisonment, escape, and brainwashing (Berkeley, CA, Los Angeles, CA, and London, 2009), p. 153; Dennis A. Pluchinsky, Anti-American terrorism: from Eisenhower to Trump: a chronicle of the threat and response (2 vols., London, 2020), I, p. 198. Quote from Blinkhorn, ‘Ultimate act’, p. 200.
12 Petra Terhoeven, ‘Victimhood and acknowledgment: the other side of terrorism’, European History Yearbook, 19 (2018), pp. 1–17, at p. 4; see also Cheryl Lawther, ‘The construction and politicization of victimhood’, in Orla Lynch and Javier Argomaniz, eds., Victims of terrorism: a comparative and interdisciplinary study (London, 2014), pp. 10–30, esp. pp. 10–16.
13 On the history of intimacy, see George Morris, ‘Historiographical review of intimacy in modern British history’, Historical Journal, 64 (2021), pp. 796–811.
14 See Peter N. Stearns and Carol Z. Stearns, ‘Emotionology: clarifying the history of emotions and emotional standards’, American Historical Review, 90 (1985), pp. 813–36; Joanna Bourke, ‘Fear and anxiety: writing about emotion in modern history’, History Workshop Journal, 55 (2003), pp. 111–33; idem, ‘Pain: metaphor, body, and culture in Anglo-American societies between the eighteenth and twentieth centuries’, Rethinking History, 18 (2014), pp. 475–98; Ute Frevert, Mächtige Gefühle: Von A wie Angst bis Z wie Zuneigung – Deutsche Geschichte seit 1900 (Frankfurt am Main, 2020).
15 Thomas Strentz, ‘Law enforcement policy and ego defenses of the hostage’, FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin, 48 (1979), pp. 2–12, at pp. 11–12.
16 Bourke, ‘Fear’, p. 52.
17 On trust as a voluntary and reciprocal emotion, see Ute Frevert, The moral economy of trust:
modern trajectories (London, 2014).
18 On publishers’ impact on memoirs, see Joanna Bourke, ‘Bodily pain, combat, and the politics of memoirs: between the American Civil War and the war in Vietnam’, Histoire sociale / Social History, 46 (2013), pp. 43–61, at p. 44.
19 Baepler, ‘Rewriting’, p. 181.
20 Manuel Borutta and Sakis Gekas, ‘A colonial sea: the Mediterranean, 1798–1956’, European Review of History, 19 (2012), pp. 1–13.
21 On Southern Europe, see Blinkhorn, ‘Liability’, pp. 339–40; on Morocco, see Baepler, ‘Rewriting’, pp. 179–82.
22 Rondanthi Tzanelli, ‘Haunted by the “enemy” within: brigandage, Vlachian/Albanian Greekness, Turkish “contamination”, and narratives of Greek nationhood in the Dilessi/Marathon affair (1870)’, Journal of Modern Greek Studies, 20 (2002), pp. 47–74, at p. 49; Romilly Jenkins, The Dilessi murders: Greek brigands and English hostages (London, 1961), pp. 1–21.
23 See Marco Dogo and Guido Franzinetti, eds., Disrupting and reshaping: early stages of nation-building in the Balkans (Ravenna, 2002).
24 Salvatore DiMaria, Towards a unified Italy: historical, cultural, and literary perspectives on the southern question (Cham, 2018).
25 Richard Pennell, Morocco since 1830: a history (London, 2000), pp. 121–36.
26 On earlier forms of brigandage in the area, see Michael Broers, Napoleon’s other war: bandits, rebels and their pursuers in the age of revolutions (Oxford, 2018).
27 Blinkhorn, ‘Liability’, p. 339.
28 Eric Hobsbawm, Primitive rebels: studies in archaic forms of social movement in the 19th and 20th centuries (Manchester, 1959); idem, Bandits (London, 1961).
29 DiMaria, Italy, p. 61. This holds true for the Mediterranean world in general.
30 On the English cases, see Blinkhorn, ‘Liability’; on the American hostages, see Russell D. Buhite, Lives at risk: hostages and victims in American foreign policy (Wilmington, DE, 1995), pp. 72–83; the Swiss and German cases have not been researched in depth so far.
31 See, in particular, Blinkhorn, ‘Liability’.
32 On the tragic death of three English hostages and one Italian hostage in Greece in 1870, see Jenkins, Dilessi murders.
33 See W. J. C. Moens, English travellers and Italian brigands: a narrative of capture and captivity (2 vols., London, 1866), I, pp. 223–4; Perdicaris, ‘Morocco’, p. 135.
34 See Moens, Travellers, I, p. 224, who notes that local hostages usually did not publish their kidnapping experiences since they feared the brigands’ vengeance, should they divulge any information. Moreover, because handing over the ransom to brigands was prohibited in many Mediterranean countries, admitting to having done just that in a memoir would have led to state persecution.
35 Ibid.
36 Lichtensteiger, Vier Monate; Isaak Friedli, Vier Monate unter den Briganten in Süditalien (Zurich, 1910).
37 Walter B. Harris, Morocco that was (Edinburgh and London 1921), pp. 182–98.
38 Edwart Richter, Meine Erlebnisse in der Gefangenschaft am Olymp (Leipzig, 1911).
39 Laura Beth Sherman, Fires on the mountain: the Macedonian revolutionary movement and the kidnapping of Ellen Stone (New York, NY, 1980).
40 Ellen Stone, ‘Six months among brigands’, McClure’s Magazine, 19 (May, June, July, Sept., Oct. 1902), pp. 2–14, 99–109, 222–32, 464–71, 562–70.
41 Paul Baepler, White slaves, African masters: an anthology of American barbary captivity narratives (Chicago, IL, and London, 1999); idem, ‘Captivity’; Sherman, Fires, used Stone’s articles to collect ‘facts’ about the case.
42 Perdicaris, ‘Raissuli’s hands’, pp. 514–15; Moens, Travellers, II, p. 276; Friedli, Vier Monate, p. 81.
43 Linda Colley, Capitves. Britain, empire and the world, 1600–1850 (London, 2003); Baepler, Slaves.
44 Mario Klarer, ‘Before barbary captivity narratives: slavery, ransom, and the economy of Christian virtue in The Good Gerhard (c. 1220) by Rudolf von Ems’, in idem, ed., Mediterranean slavery and world literature: captivity genres from Cervantes to Rousseau (New York, NY, 2019), pp. 25–46, at p. 25; on Indian captivity, see Michelle Burnham, Captivity & sentiment: cultural exchange in American literature, 1682–1861 (Hanover, NH, and London, 1997).
45 Marcus Hartner, ‘Toward a new literary history of captivity: adventure and generic hybridity in the late sixteenth century’, in Klarer, ed., Mediterranean slavery, pp. 47–68, at p. 47.
46 Editor’s note, Leslie’s Monthly Magazine, 58 (1904), p. 510.
47 See Moens, Travellers, II, p. vi; Richter, Erlebnisse, p. 4.
48 Quote by Alon Confino, ‘Memory and the history of mentalities’, in Astrid Erll and Ansgar Nünning, eds., Cultural memory studies: an international and interdisciplinary handbook (Berlin 2008), pp. 77–84, at p. 81. See the seminal work of Maurice Halbwachs, The collective memory (New York, NY, 1980).
49 Confino, ‘Memory’, p. 81.
50 Bourke, ‘Bodily pain’, p. 44.
51 Friedli, Vier Monate, p. 24 (my translation).
52 Perdicaris, ‘Raissuli’s hands’, pp. 518–19, 522, quotes: pp. 519, 520.
53 Harris, Morocco, p. 181.
54 Perdicaris, ‘Raissuli’s hands’, p. 522; Richter, Erlebnisse, p. 37.
55 Stone, ‘Six months’, June, p. 106.
56 Moens, Travellers, I, p. 219.
57 Stone, ‘Six months’, May, p. 14.
58 Moens, Travellers, I, p. 157; Richter, Erlebnisse, p. 30; Friedli, Vier Monate, p. 23.
59 George L. Mosse, The image of man: the creation of modern masculinity (New York, NY, 1998), p. 25.
60 Sander S. Gilman, Making the body beautiful: a cultural history of aesthetic surgery (Princeton, NJ, and Oxford, 1999), esp. ch. 3: ‘The racial nose’.
61 Bourke, ‘Bodily pain’, p. 49.
62 See esp. Raewyn Connell and James W. Messerschmidt, ‘Hegemonic masculinity: rethinking the concept’, Gender & Society, 19 (2005), pp. 829–59; John Tosh, Manliness and masculinities in nineteenth-century Britain: essays on gender, family and empire (Harlow, 2005).
63 Richter, Erlebnisse, p. 39; Moens, Travellers, II, p. 221; Friedli, Vier Monate, p. 16.
64 On male-coded pain language in female accounts, see Bourke, ‘Bodily pain’, p. 49.
65 Moens, Travellers, I, p. 264.
66 Ibid.
67 Ibid., pp. 307, 302, 299.
68 See Carolyn Burdett, ‘Emotions’, in Juliet John, ed., The Oxford handbook of Victorian literary culture (Oxford, 2014), pp. 580–97, at p. 582.
69 On narrating male anxiety in nineteenth-century England, see Henry French and Mark Rothery, ‘Male anxiety among younger sons of the English landed gentry’, Historical Journal, 62 (2019), pp. 967–95.
70 Moens, Travellers, I, p. 140.
71 Perdicaris, ‘Raissuli’s hands’, p. 514; Friedli, Vier Monate, p. 69 (my translation).
72 Stone, ‘Six months’, May, p. 13.
73 Ibid., p. 16; ibid., June, p. 102.
74 Moens, Travellers, II, pp. 14–16.
75 Harris, Morocco, pp. 188–9.
76 Friedli, Vier Monate, p. 23 (my translation).
77 Virginia Smith, Clean: a history of personal hygiene and purity (Oxford and New York, NY, 2007), pp. 284–5; Anne McClintock, Imperial leather: race, gender, and sexuality in the colonial conquest (New York, NY, 1995), p. 208.
78 Stone, ‘Six months’, May, p. 12.
79 Ibid.
80 McClintock, Imperial leather, p. 212.
81 Stone, ‘Six months’, June, p. 101.
82 Chamber’s Journal, 3 Mar. 1866, p. 133.
83 Charles Dickens, review of Moens, Travellers, in All the Year Round, 3 Feb. 1866, p. 92; Times, 6 Feb. 1866, p. 12.
84 Advertisement for Moens, Travellers, in Spectator, 3 Mar. 1866, p. 256.
85 Advertisement for Perdicaris, ‘Raissuli’s hands’, in Minneapolis Journal, 23 Aug. 1904, p. 7; ‘Miss Stone’s release’, Age Herald, 27 Feb. 1902; ‘Fared hard, like Miss Stone’, Sun, 20 Apr. 1902, p. 5.
86 ‘Correspondent’s hunt for Miss Stone: adventures of a writer for the London Daily Graphic among Balkan brigands’, Republic, 19 Jan. 1902, p. 8.
87 Dawson, Graham, Soldier heroes, British adventure, empire and the imagining of masculinities (London, 1994), p. 54Google Scholar.
88 Moens, Travellers, I, pp. 271–2.
89 Friedli, Vier Monate, p. 85 (my translation).
90 Perdicaris, ‘Raissuli’s hands’, p. 522.
91 Archivio dello Stato di Salerno, Prefettura, Busta 59, Fascicolo 607.
92 Ugo Di Pace, ‘Raffaele Del Pozzo: fotografo dei briganti’, afterword to Johann Jakob Lichtensteiger, Quattro mesi fra i briganti 1865/6, ed. Ugo Di Pace (Avagliano, 1984), pp. 111–44.
93 Baepler, ‘Captivity’, p. 206.
94 Forbes, Rosita, The sultan of the mountains: the life story of Raisuli (New York, NY, 1924), p. 62Google Scholar.
95 Sonnichsen, Albert, Confessions of a Macedonian bandit (New York, NY, 1909), pp. 256, 261Google Scholar.
96 Lawther, ‘Construction’, p. 16.
97 See Dickens’s review, p. 93; Stephen Bonsal, ‘Raisuli the brigand who made himself king’, Harper’s Weekly, 2 Mar. 1907, p. 33; ‘Spencer Eddy asserts that the brigands who kidnaped missionary are patriots’, Salt Lake Herald, 24 Feb. 1902, p. 1.
98 Perdicaris, ‘Morocco’, p. 142.
99 State Archives St Gallen, Switzerland, W 54/78, 6.
100 Ministero dell’Interno, Segretario Generale to Sig. Prefetto di Salerno, Rome, 27 Dec. 1871, Archivio di Stato di Salerno, Busta 59, Fascicolo 607.